Captain Frances Dalyell alias Mrs Pierson

-

Every so often a little snippet of information turns into a day of book diving and visiting some of the more esoteric corners of the world wide web. 

Ballads such as The Valiant Commander with his Resolute Lady tell us of women wearing men's clothes and taking up arms; and, there are many myths and legends of women donning men's clothes to fight in the wars - but is this fact or fiction? The lot of camp followers and the women working as spies is relatively well documented (in C17th terms that is!) but did women cross dress and actually get to the sharp pointy end of things? 


Professor Mark Stoyle of Southampton University investigated, and wrote a paper on the subject

(I)n 1643, a draft proclamation was drawn up, setting out required standards of behaviour for Charles I’s army. It included a hand-written memo in the margin from the king himself stating ‘lett no woman presume to counterfeit her sex by wearing mans apparall under payne of the severest punishment’.

These words suggest the king believed female cross-dressing was quite widespread in his army and show a willingness on his part to take a much firmer line on the practice – particularly in relation to prostitutes. Curiously though, when the proclamation was finally published it contained no reference to cross-dressing.

For those of you without an academic log in, there's an abridged version on the BBC History magazine site.

So it really was a 'thing' and not a plot device from the 1980s TV drama 'By the Sword Divided'

A discussion over on Twitter led to the following investigation into a female Captain of Horse fighting for the King, first with Montrose and then with Newcastle.

Captain Frances Dalziel/Dalyell/Dalzell (alias Mrs Pierson)

Clearly not Captain Frances: one of the many women from the Sealed Knot/ECWS who entertain us on summer bank holiday weekends

Frances was very definitely a real person, and very definitely fought in the wars.

Born in Scotland, she was allegedly the illegitimate daughter of the Earl of Carnwath.

Frances first appears as a captain in Earl of Crawford’s Regiment of Horse, and she led her troop on Montrose's brief campaign into Dumfries in April 1644. Her cornet was black with the motto “I DARE” and the motif of a naked man in a gibbet.

After Dumfries Prince Rupert took command of what troops Montrose had, and it would appear around this time that her troop transferred to Lord Eythin’s Regiment of Horse serving as part of the Marquis of Newcastle’s army

A Frances Dalyell (alias Mrs Pierson) appears in Reid's Cavalier Army Lists listed as serving in Lord Eythin’s Regiment of Horse, she appears in the regiment in June 1644. Reid’s lists are primarily based upon “A List of Officers Claiming to the Sixty Thousand Pounds &c. Granted by His Sacred Majesty for the Relief of His True-Loyal and Indigent Party” (known as Indigent Officers or IO).

She also appears in some contemporary depositions:

“in the commissione granted be the Marques of Newcastell to hir, Captane Francis Dalzell” 

J. Erskine. “10 Junij 1644. Major John Arskyne's examination”

I sense an extra troop of horse for Montrose's Army needs to be planned. I see myself utilising the harquebusier with helmet officer with a headswap from the female heads pack. For those of you who are acolytes of the church of not15mm* Bad Squiddo have expressed an interest in producing her in miniature form.

For those of you interested in other (possible) female combatants, we've already come across the story of Trooper Jane of Ripley Castle in Houses of Interest: North Yorkshire.


Next to be researched is the Evesham soldier mentioned in The Scottish Dove (December 1645) a foot soldier from the garrison of Gloucester who got caught out having some clothes made...


*shame on you! You are heathen unbelievers who will strain your eyes trying to paint in all that minute detail, repent now and turn to the true light of 15mm

If you enjoyed reading this, or any of the other posts, please consider supporting the blog. 
Thanks.

Comments

  1. Dex McHenry1 December 2020 at 14:40

    A splendid overview. I've recently started building camp bases for Baroque in 15mm. I'd been contemplating a base suggesting a camp brothel so the idea of prostitutes in breeches is a good idea, even if it might demand a bit of conversion.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Radar1 December 2020 at 15:05

      Thanks Dex. Have a look on here using the label 'civilians' listed under allegiance.

      Blue Moon make a camp pack
      Donnington have useful camp hardware.
      Matchlock have some useful stuff under ECW personalities
      Minifigs have a look at the Hussite Wars section in renaissance, a nice camp followers pack.
      Museum is the place to look for carts.
      Peter Pig have a women's heads pack. Also look in pirates and WotR ranges for useful stuff.
      QRF/Freikorps 15 have a super pack of camp followers in their ECW/30YW range - includes children.

      Delete
    2. Dex McHenry1 December 2020 at 18:05

      Cheers Radar. I have plenty of wagons etc (including loads of the old Hallmark ones). It is the civilian figures I need in the main. I picked up some of the Magister Militum camp groups and the Matchlock personalities (although they can be very hit or miss in terms of fulfilling an order it seems, and not all the castings still seem to be available). I have been tempted by the Blue Moon camp but have the idea they are closer to 18mm and wondered how they'd mix in. The big uncertainty for me is ECW era tents. I have a copy of Wagner's European Weapons and Warfare of the 30 Years War which has some good illustrations, notably of thatched huts and stabling. It may be back to good old scratch building!

      Delete
    3. Radar1 December 2020 at 18:44

      Yes the Blue Moon stuff is 18mm.
      Baueda have a Byzantine ridge tent that is quite appropriate.

      Delete
  2. DeanM2 December 2020 at 14:14

    Very interesting history - great to see those reenactors too1

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Radar2 December 2020 at 14:40

      Frances seems to be one of the few women soldiers who did actually exist as a soldier; many of the stories concerning women soldiers seem to have been embellished by the Victorians to the point that any basis of truth has been lost.

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Colonel Philip O’Reilly of Ballynacargy’s Troop of Horse

-
Image
Somehow, despite the best efforts of real life trying to hinder my painting of little men, I've managed to make some more progress on my Catholic Confederation army. Here's the second of two units of cavalry. Philip MacHugh O'Reilly was the son of Hugh O'Reilly of Ballynacargy, County Cavan, and Katherine MacMahon. The family were deemed to be one of the ‘deserving’ native Irish families whose land was not taken during the Ulster plantation. Not to be confused with Hugh O'Reilly, the Catholic Archbishop of Armagh. Contemporary sources refer to him as a lawyer, but there's no existing evidence of him having attended Inns of Court in England. He may well have received legal training on the Continent, prior to accepting a command in the French army.  Philip inherited the family estate on his return to Ireland. He would play an active role in local politics, holding a number of important roles, before being elected as MP for County Cavan in the 1640 parliament. As M...
Read more

Royalist Harquebusiers on Foot

-
Image
  Bit of an eye candy post today; where I finally get around to painting the Royalist harquebusiers on foot (they've only been sat in the 'to do' pile for nine months or so). For those of you new to KeepYourPowderDry, or the Civil Wars in general, you might be wondering why anyone would want dismounted cavalry. In a nutshell regiments of horse joined in the besieging of houses, but as horses weren't particularly useful when attacking a house, their riders dismounted to fight. They were often in the first wave of assault troops as their buff coats and armour afforded them considerable protection (in comparison to infantry). Plus it also gave them a share of any spoils if the assault was successful. For more information about the role of harquebusiers in sieges, and a look at my existing assault parties see  here . These are Steel Fist figures from pack ECWF 09, but as I have zero faith in Steel Fist swords (they are much too slender to be practical) I have replaced th...
Read more

Firenze

-
Image
Firenze/Florence? Well known exile location or has the ECWtravelogue decided to embark upon the grand tour? And what exactly has the birthplace of the renaissance got to do with the Wars of the Three Kingdoms? In all fairness, your immediate reaction of 'well that's got nothing to do with the Wars of the Three Kingdoms' would be correct. What Firenze did have was a ridiculously wealthy Edwardian Anglo-Italian gentleman, called Frederick Stibbert. An English pot Museo Stibbert.  Stibbert's family was incredibly wealthy, his grandfather making a fortune from his role as General Commander of the East India Company, and governor of Bengal.  You can get very close to many of the exhibits, possibly too close; but this brilliant to be able to see details that we normally see through a glass display cabinet  Stibbert's father would be a colonel in the Coldstream Guards; and, through a series of deaths in the family, Frederick would inherit the entire vast fortune. On the hi...
Read more

General Eoghan Ruadh Ó Néill’s Regiment of Foot

-
Image
Who? You might be more familiar if I write Eoghan Ruadh Ó Néill as Owen Roe O'Neill. But I won't because he was Irish, not English. Although there is some confusion if he was Eoghan Rua or Eoghan Ruadh. I'll stick with Eoghan Ruadh. Now please bear with me, as there's rather a lot of Ó Néills running around Ireland in the 1640s. Eoghan Ruadh had at least eight brothers and four sisters; and was connected through marriage to many of the leading native Irish families of Ulster. His nephews included Daniel O'Neill  and Hugh Dubh O'Neill both of whom were important figures in 1640s Ireland, as well as Conor, Lord Maguire, one of the original plotters of the 1641 rebellion, and his brother Ruari , who commanded a regiment in the Ulster army during the 1640s. In Spanish service, 1605–41 Eoghan Ruadh was accompanied by three of hisbrothers: Phelim, Art Óg, and Cormac. He secured himself a position as captain in the regiment of Henry O'Neill, son of the Earl of Tyro...
Read more

Novelty and Change

-
Image
The weather is rubbish: it doesn't feel right painting in the summer, but it is much too cold and wet to go on a big ECWtravelogue day out... so expect rather a lot of book related posts of the coming weeks. Helion curate a number of regular conferences linked to their extensive book series. I was lucky to attend the most recent Century of the Soldier conference as a guest of series editor Charles Singleton. The lectures given by the speakers are collated and published  by Helion with the subtitle of "Proceedings of the... Helion and Company 'Century of the Soldier' Conference". I must be clear and point out that Helion sent me this copy for review. So, what is this? A nice souvenir for everyone who attended? Or the 'handouts' for everyone who couldn't be bothered taking notes? If you didn't attend, is it worth splashing the cash? Clearly, at a very facetious level it is both a nice souvenir, and the 'handouts' from the lectures, for those ...
Read more

Soldiers' Clothing of the Early 17th Century

-
Image
The latest tome from Helion focuses on an issue that is right up there in the list of favourite topics at Château KeepYourPowderDry. Occasionally Helion send me books to review, for clarity I bought my copy. I might not be the intended audience for this book, as I know a little bit about the subject, and my bookshelves groan with the weight of Civil War books. But I bought it none the less. Laurence Spring is one of those Civil War historians/researchers whose books will always make me sit up and take notice.  This volume, unsurprisingly, takes a long hard look at clothing issues to soldiers both in Britain and also on the continent. I'm going to be honest, I've not read the 30YW chapters (plus I feel unqualified to comment upon their accuracy), but I have read the 'British' chapters four times. Yes, four. I'm that sad. On the subject of my copy being well thumbed, the cover is, somewhat disappointingly, already delaminating. Not good. This book is chock-full of acc...
Read more

Amsterdam

-
Image
 Amsterdam? English Civil War? Surely a questionable/tenuous link... or an excuse for a 'jolly'. Amsterdam, party capital of the low countries, is not too synonymous with the Civil Wars, standing in the shadows of Breda and The Hague. Detail from 'Militia Company...Bicker' Breda's claim is strong, where many adventuring young gentlemen learned soldiering before the outbreak of the Wars; The Hague, where so many Royalists exiled themselves during the Interregnum/Protectorate.  Amsterdam wasn't too popular with exiled Royalists; however, it did become home for many exiled republicans once the Restoration had returned the monarch to the throne. These exiled republicans would help build Amsterdam's wealth. What Amsterdam does have is a city landscape that very much entered its golden age during the mid seventeenth century. Amongst the pungent aroma of cafes, stroopwafels, extortionate chocolate shops, frites and ladies whose virtue can be easily bought, are a wh...
Read more

Comments. Again (!)

-
Image
Sorry regular readers, once again comments and the contact form have temporarily been turned off. Why? Someone on Twitter has got their knickers in a twist about an information panel at Newark Castle.  Why has she done that? Because the information board features an image of a man of African descent.  The man pictured is an actor, portraying a man called John Americanus, who fought for the King at Newark. John's role in the defence of Newark is well documented. And yes, John was of African descent. The National Civil War Centre created a Civil War Trail around the town, information panels are located at points of interest. These panels feature QR codes which accessed features on a now defunct smartphone app. Each location also featured an eye witness account - stories from real people who witnessed the events in Newark. Each information panel has a photographic representation of the person whose story was told in the app. The Castle's eyewitness account was John Americanus. Un...
Read more

Prison Wagon

-
Image
I've watched enough nonsense on the telly box to know that every historical/supernatural setting requires a prison wagon (effectively a cage on wheels) in which the good people round up witches/monsters, or alternatively the evil henchmen (who are all, almost certainly, called Igor) round up innocent civilians to aid their master's fiendish plans. (delete as appropriate). In fact, spurred on by a regular reader (hello), and their questions about Witchfinder General they asked me where my prison wagon was. Well, as I didn't have on, nor any excuse to not have one, I was spurred into action. I decided to utilise the chassis of Donnington Miniatures' CB14 Open 4 Wheel Wagon. The wagon comes as a kit, flat bed, separate sides and baggage. I ditched the sides, and will utilise the baggage elsewhere. Four Museum Miniatures' draught horses from my spares box will pull the cart. But how to fabricate the 'cage'? A few test pieces proved that I could utilise matches a...
Read more

KeepYourPowderDry has made it to 7!

-
Image
Austrian mountaineer Heinrich Harrer spent seven years in Tibet, nice work if you can get it; his story was turned into a film, and Harrer was portrayed by Brad Pitt. In years to come who will portray me in the film version of this blog? When I started writing this blog it was a receptacle for bits of paper that didn't really have a 'home', so I gave them one; but the 'home' has grown and developed a life of its own. Almost.  Regular readers will be surprised to hear that the Saturday boy did not attend this year's KYPD staff mid-winter party - management's bluff of compulsory playing of 'Mould-my-Cockle-Bread'* obviously scared him off  I genuinely never expected anyone to read my ramblings, but read them you do.  Every year, sometime about October I do start to wonder what the viewing figures for the year will be: will it be 50k?, will it be 100k?, this year I started wondering if it would break the 250k figure. It passed that with ease in November...
Read more