Warlord Pike and Shotte Epic Battles: the infantry sprue

-

Firstly a big thank you to Warlord Games who sent me a sprue of their new Pike and Shotte Epic Battles infantry.

(You can see how I got on with the cavalry sprue here.)

I will try and look at these figures from three different angles: the first impression of someone completely new to the period, the button counter’s standpoint, and then from a seasoned wargamer’s point of view. In all cases I'm looking at these through Wars of the Three Kingdoms spectacles. (Wars of the Three Kingdoms is a more accurate name for the conflicts that were fought in the British Isles in the mid seventeenth century. The English Civil War was just one of these conflicts.)

The obligatory next to a ruler picture (the ruler is lined up with the soles of their footwear)

The 'new to the period' view
This one sprue provides enough figures for one unit (a Regiment of Foot or RoF). Figures look very detailed, moulding is clean and crisp with no flash and only minimal mould lines. The pikes look a bit delicate, will they survive? (see the seasoned wargamer bit below)

The highlighted hands - have these pikemen got one arm longer than the other? It would be very difficult trying to hold a pike this low down 

The pikeman strips – there are some hands holding pikes that look a bit odd, once you notice them you can’t but notice them. Perhaps if the hands were holding the pikes a millimetre or two higher up the pike they wouldn’t look quite so incongruous.

All in all they look excellent, where do I sign up?


The button counter’s view (or hair splitters anonymous)
The figures have a dual life, being marketed for those who want to recreate the 30YW and those that want to represent the ECW. So it is inevitable that the strips will be a compromise.

The pikemen strips look good, men all have hangers (short swords), there is a good mix of armoured (including with and without tassets), and unarmoured. The pikemen all have morion helmets, it would be good to see a slightly wider range of headgear on the pikemen (a few broad brimmed hats, some monteroes and monmouth caps). It's glaringly obvious that the sculptors' source material was limited to the very flawed and dated Haythornthwaite.

Pikes are a little on the short side, but this might be a compromise due to the constraints of manufacture and material properties (following the very rough rule of thumb that pikes should be thrice the height of the men the pikes are about 5mm too short - for an in-depth explanation see here). 5mm doesn't sound much but it equates to about 0.6 metres in real life (or 2 foot for those of you who haven't embraced modernity).

The musketeers, again are pretty good, I can only really level two faults at the musketeer strips – headgear and spacing. Certainly from an ECW standpoint there are probably too many broad brimmed hats and not enough monteros and monmouth caps. 

On the subject of headwear wargamers' favourite™ Newcastle's whitecoats will need quite a few Scot's blew bonnets in their ranks ('blew bonnets' does not simply mean blue hats, they are the same blue beret type headgear worn by the Scots). Royalist regiments that benefitted from the Oxford clothing issue will require a very heavy proportion of monteroes amongst their numbers. 

The musketeers are much too close together, but that is more of a style issue (the Epic strips are tightly packed for a mass effect on a minimal footprint). These are very much generic musketeers, there is quite a bit of evidence that Royalist musketeers tended to use cartridge bags rather than bandoliers with chargers (the oft incorrectly named 'apostles'). The musketeers all have musket rests, which is fine (it is also a misnomer that rests were no longer used after the early years of the wars - they were still used, but lighter weapons were becoming more plentiful that didn't necessitate the use of a rest). If you have your sights set on recreating the Army Newly Modelled, then these are not for you I'm afraid. You'll be better served looking elsewhere, at metal figures.

The separate pikemen are the strongest point on the sprue, although they do seem a little beefier than the figures in strips.

Good to see that only officers, ensigns and the drummer are wearing a scarf (usually incorrectly called a sash).

The sprue as a whole provides you with a RoF that has a ratio of 1:1, ideally a RoF should be at 2:1 (in favour of musketeers). This is a bit of a wargamer thing of 1:1 dating back to the Gush rules, wings or sleeves of musketeers should actually be the same depth as the pike block.

Considering that there is a line of pike at port, it does seem a little strange there isn't a musket firing line.

If you are inspired by contemporary illustrations (such as Streeter's Plan of Naseby) it is a shame there are no separate halberdiers (maybe they'll be a later add on pack?).

The seasoned wargamer
Seasoned wargamers know best. Not historians, not wargames companies, not figure sculptors. And even they can't agree with one another. Everyone has their own preconception of what things should look like.

The seasoned wargamer will probably have views on the Epic figures somewhere between the 'new to the period' and the 'button counter'. But they will be wondering how can they change what is presented to how they want their finished RoF to look.

Pikes - they'll break, they are too short, I don't like plastic pikes.
I've tried to snap some pikes, bending them at 90 degrees to the figure's head. If that is how you regularly treat your figures then plastic figures are probably not for you. The pikes did require straightening, I then repeated the bend in the opposite direction, again required straightening, the pikes do now show a white line of weakness on the bend mark. Only on the third  bend did they break. So yes they will break, but you really have to go out of your way to purposefully break them.

They will break - eventually!

If you do break a pike, or want to replace all the pikes with plastic bristles or wire pikes: good luck is all I can say. If you have managed to break a pike, replace them rather than trying to repair - save yourself a lot of time and mither.

Pike cut away

Pikes are moulded the full length of the pikeman. You will need to carve the moulded bit of pike away. This leaves a figure that really doesn't look very good, this carved area will be hidden by the  replacement pike. I've never drilled out or modified plastic figures, so I'm on a steep learning curve (and my first attempt has been pretty heavy handed so looks a little brutalised. I've managed to mangle the helmet with my pin vise!) Certainly doable if you are so inclined, but I really wouldn't want to have drill out hundreds of the blessed things. If separate pikes are a make or break for you I'd strongly suggest that you look elsewhere.

A steep learning curve: a lot of cleaning up and a coat of paint and you can hide him at the back. Realistically, don't bother - life is too short

I want to cut the strips in half and make smaller sized units. The closeness of the figures doesn't easily lend itself to doing this (unlike the original ACW Epic strips). The effort involved, not to mention the greenstuff  skill level required (to make good the cut), means that cutting the strips isn't really a viable option.

I want a firing line and extra ensigns and officers, what other manufacturers' figures can I use?

from l-r: PP Scot (note very undersized pike), Naismith, PP regular pike, Epic, PP Scot, Epic

First, let's talk about figure size. When Warlord released their original Epic ACW range the figures were deemed to be 'Epic size' a unique 13.5mm. The Epic ranges have slowly crept up in size, so much so that the Epic P&S range is comparable to 'true 15mm' (the original Epic ACW line was somewhere between large 10mm and true 15mm). Of course Epic P&S might be 13.5mm, because there is no standard way of sizing toy soldiers - is it to the eye? Top of the head? A vague approximation? Who knows? Certainly above my pay grade. I wonder if what is commonly known as 'true 15' will soon be known as 'Epic'?

from l-r: Steel Fist, Magister Militum, Naismith, Epic, PP Scot, PP, Essex, Museum, Matchlock

For those of you who have perused KeepYourPowderDry before you will know that all my figures are what can be called 'true 15mm'. I've had a rummage through my spares box to pick out some likely candidates for a size match - Peter Pig (PP), Steel Fist and Naismith*. One range that should also marry up sizewise are Magister Militum, but alas no unpainted figures to drop into the line-up. You can gauge how they fit by reading my Which Figures? series of posts.

Epic, Steel Fist, Epic, PP Scot (the Scots are slightly shorter than the rest of the PP range)

If you would like to read my thoughts on the cavalry sprue see here.

* Naismith are out of production, a handful of packs are still available from Keep Wargaming (no relation). Caveat: see my notes on Naismith in the What Figures? posts linked to above.


If you enjoyed reading this, or any of the other posts, please consider supporting the blog. 
Thanks.


Popular posts from this blog

Newark's Defences - a town under siege

-
Image
The ECWtravelogue has visited Newark many times. The King, Queen Henrietta Maria, Prince Rupert all visited; it is home to the National Civil War Centre ; and is the location of possibly the best preserved Civil War earthwork - The Queen's Sconce . So why does it deserve another blog entry? In a word: Clampe's Plan ( but that's two! ). Clampe drew a plan of the Royalist defences of Newark and the Parliamentarian, and Scots siege lines. There's also another, slightly different, later version of the map: Buck's Map, which is held in the Royal Collection and can be viewed online here . The Queen's Sconce survived, did anything else? Clampe's Plan  I've seen photographs of other earthworks in Newark, but no locations for them. A little sleuthery comparing Nottingham's register of ancient monuments, and Historic England's records has resulted in an extensive list of sites. Unfortunately, the locations are so complex that they don't fit my normal
Read more

Trees

-
Image
It has been said of wargamers that they spend all their time painstakingly painting figures and then ignore the terrain. A trend that I feel is changing for the better with printed game mats and 'teddy bear fur'.   Today's post looks at trees: more specifically, Woodland Scenics deciduous Realistic Tree Kits. 2"-3" trees, light green foliage, PP and SF figures for comparison Warning: great trees, messy process. The trees come in several different sizes. Packaging varies, sample kits consisting of armatures and foliage are available, or alternatively elements can be bought separately. They all 'work' the same regardless of 'version'. 2"-3" on the left, 3"-5" on the right I've gone for the 2"-3" armatures and 3" - 5" armatures. Armatures are tree trunk brown plastic and look very uninspiring when you first encounter them., as they are 2 dimensional. But do not be put off, the 2D branches can be bent and the
Read more

Houses of Interest: West Yorkshire

-
Image
For more Yorkshire 'related stuff' you can find North Yorkshire here ,  South Yorkshire here ,   East Riding here . See also the Rupert Travelogue  entry for Yorkshire, and the entry for Adwalton Moor Oakwell Hall    was the inspiration for Charlotte Brontë's Fieldhead in "Shirley". More recently it has been used a number of times as a film set, including "Jonathan Strange and Mr Norrell". Located close to the M62 and the Leeds branch of purgatory on Earth (aka Ikea), this Tudor manor house is beautifully maintained by Kirklees Borough Council. The hall is presented as a seventeenth century home. I really like this approach, as so often historic houses have different rooms decorated for different eras, so it is really nice to see a house presented from one era in it's entirety. Oakwell was in the ownership of the Batt family, who supported the King; John Batt was a captain and most probably fought at Adwalton Moor. The retreating Parli
Read more

My Kingdom For A Horse (1991)

-
Image
Civil War films are, to say the least, thin on the ground. So, forgive me for scraping the bottom of the barrel. My Kingdom For A Horse was a BBC made for TV play written by John Godber. The protagonist, 31 year old, still living with his parents, history teacher Steve is played by Sean Bean.  Steve and his best friend Pud, are pikemen in the Sealed Knot. Unfortunately for Steve, his head of department is also a member of the Sealed Knot, even more unfortunately he's the 'muster master general'. With the backdrop of the Sealed Knot, Airfix 54mm ECW miniatures, and frequent references to Marston Moor, Cromwell, and the New Model Army, the dour Steve plods through life in a dilapidated Yorkshire secondary school. No spoilers, but everyone who has ever taught in a secondary school will do an internal cheer when Steve has a showdown with the school bully. There's some seriously big hair, floppy fringes, brown suits, a school held up by ACRO props (nothing changed there then
Read more

Comments. Again (!)

-
Image
Sorry regular readers, once again comments and the contact form have temporarily been turned off. Why? Someone on Twitter has got their knickers in a twist about an information panel at Newark Castle.  Why has she done that? Because the information board features an image of a man of African descent.  The man pictured is an actor, portraying a man called John Americanus, who fought for the King at Newark. John's role in the defence of Newark is well documented. And yes, John was of African descent. The National Civil War Centre created a Civil War Trail around the town, information panels are located at points of interest. These panels feature QR codes which accessed features on a now defunct smartphone app. Each location also featured an eye witness account - stories from real people who witnessed the events in Newark. Each information panel has a photographic representation of the person whose story was told in the app. The Castle's eyewitness account was John Americanus. Unf
Read more

Houses of Interest: Staffordshire

-
Image
The  ECW Travelogue turns its attention on Staffordshire. For some reason, rather than starting the entry at the bit of Staffs that is 'next door' to  Château KeepYourPowderDry I started with the corner of Staffs that was furthest away. The first entries look at the escape of Charles II after the Battle of Worcester. Of course any post about Staffordshire requires, by law, pictures of Staffordshire slipware - this one by Thomas Toft; Potteries Museum, Hanley First up is Moseley Old Hall  on the outskirts of Wolverhampton, and is cared for by the National Trust. Moseley bills itself as "the home that saved a king" - considering the number of close calls that Charles had during his escape, this isn't really the unique selling point that you might expect it to be. I do wonder how many other houses, along the Monarch's Way could also make that claim? Built about 1600, the National Trust have recreated a seventeenth century garden on the estate. A rather s
Read more

Coat Colours Part 2: Royalist Regiments of Foot

-
Image
Continuing my therapeutic blogging (write rather than rant) antidote to incorrect English Civil War coat colour tables for wargamers, I give you the Royalist Regiments of Foot. For all of my coat colour articles see: Introduction   Part 1  Parliamentarian coat colours Part 3  Scots coat colours Part 3B  Montrose and the Irish Brigade Part 4  Dragoons, Horse and the New Model Army coat colours The Trained Bands London Trained Bands Auxiliary regiments Scarves   Same rules apply here, as they did with the Parliamentarian coat colours: Regiments often got renamed when command passed to a new colonel - these regiments are listed under their first name e.g. Jacob Astley's Regiment was originally Richard Fielding's Regiment. Coat colour notes refer to contemporaneous references and some of the deductions made by Reid, Spring,  Peachey and Prince. You will also notice that some regiments have several coat colours listed. Where there is some question around a coat colour I have t
Read more

Coat Colours Part 1: Parliamentarian Regiments of Foot

-
Image
When I first started my Civil War gaming project I relied upon the many ECW coat colour tables on wargaming websites. As my project has progressed, my library has got bigger, my research has gone back to primary sources rather than relying upon second and third hand sources; and I have noticed quite a few errors in these lists for wargamers. I have also noticed the same errors appearing in multiple lists.     As a result of continually seeing 'the London Trained Bands and their Auxiliaries wore red coats' (there is no evidence supporting this at all, the evidence, whilst not explicit suggests that the London Trained Bands wore civilian clothes - some of the Auxiliaries might have been issued with blue winter coats) I decided to write my own list.  So here it is. If your allegiance lies elsewhere you might want to look at  Introduction   Part 2  Royalist coat colours Part 3  Scots coat colours Part 3B  Montrose and the Irish Brigade Pa
Read more

Lurkio ECW Range

-
Image
Always on the look out for new toys, I spotted Lurkio have started releasing their new ECW range after a bit of a hiatus. Thank you to Lurkio for kindly sending me some figures for review. My favourite figure from the samples I was sent, not quite sure what has happened to his face though I'll be very straight here, these might not be to everybody's taste. Why? They are headless (yay!) and the pikemen are open handed (double yay!). Whilst that makes me very happy, I know that many baulk at the idea of having to assemble teeny bits on figures, and see any assembly on anything smaller than 28mm figures a complete no-no.  The return of the scale-o-matic, horizontal lines are at 5mm spacing For those of you new to this 'sticking things together' game it isn't a problem, in fact it is pretty straightforward*. I find putting a big blob of superglue onto a palette, then use a cocktail stick as a glue spreader, the best way to get superglue into the precise area that you wa
Read more

Pikes

-
Image
I must not write "don't tell him your name Pike".  I must not write "don't tell him your name Pike". Oh damn! Pikemen figures come in two varieties, with cast on pikes, and open handed. Having previously owned 6mm ECW pikemen armed with pikes which quickly turn to overcooked spaghetti, I went the open handed pikemen route.  For those of you who choose this path, open handed pikemen raises two questions: how long should a pike be?, and where can I buy pikes from?  All this gives me an excuse to have a closer look at the 'queen of weapons'. How long should a pike be? You'd think that this question would be fairly easy to answer, it is in fact more than a little problematical. Pikes were between 15' and 18' in length, which should be quite easy to scale down, or so you would think. Sir James Turner  (Pallas Armata p.176) and General Monck (Observations p.26) both stated that the proper length for a pike should be 18'.The 1639 Direction
Read more